Study

Comparative Technique

Size (age range)

Measured POD

Conclusions

Shah** (2002) [13]

Monopolar

34 (4 - 7 yrs)

1 - 10

Less thermal damage with Coblation. No difference in pain, diet, activity, or return to work

Stoker (2004) [7]

Monopolar

89 (3 - 12 yrs)

1 - 14

No difference in pain, diet, or activity

Parsons (2006) [9]

Harmonic Scalpel, Monopolar

61 (3 - 12 yrs)

1 - 10

No difference in diet or activity

Shapiro (2007) [14]

Cold dissection with bipolar

47 (2 - 16 yrs)

1 - 14

Decreased operative time No difference in pain, pain medications, diet, activity, or return to work

Parker (2009) [15]

Cold dissection with bipolar

70 (4 - 15 yrs)

1,3, 6, 8, 10

Less pain medications at 12 Hours. Decreased pain only on POD6. No difference in diet

Gustavii (2010) [16]

Cold dissection with bipolar

34 (6 - 18 yrs)

1 - 14

No difference in pain or pain medications

Jones (2011) [17]

Monopolar

61 (4 - 20 yrs)

0, 2, 14

No difference in pain